How Google’s Local Pack Update has Reshaped the Organic Landscape

What happened?

On August 7th, Google rolled out a seemingly small but incredibly significant update to the manner in which it displays local businesses within its web results.

Instead of the traditional 7-pack map results, Google updated its format to display a greatly reduced (but expandable) 3-pack local listing format (aka Google Local Snack Pack).

Old Format:



oldformat-example-Google Search

New Format

newformat-example-Google Search


What is most significant about this update though is not the change in the display format itself, but the frequency with which the new 3-pack local listings show up and their visibility in the search results, compared to the previous 7-pack of results.


Google’s focus has been shifting heavily towards localizing search results over the past year for keywords that either have an expressed or implied local intent. This can be seen in their Pigeon update, map changes, the coming and going of local carousels, and even their mobile friendly update.

Our data science team first noticed the new local listing 3-pack show up starting in March/April within the hotel, vacation rental and restaurant industries. The format change rolled through UK, Australia and then Brazil since then for those industries. It’s only now, after about 3 months of originally introducing it, that the new format been completely rolled-out to nearly all keywords with a local intent.

The chart below highlights the dramatic shift in count of keywords that displayed the old 7-pack map results vs the new 3-pack local listings across our research data set of 1 million keywords.


How extensive is the impact?

In order to quantify the true impact of this change, we took our research data set of >1 million keywords and went about determining the comparative visibility of map results vs. local listings.

Our methodology:

  1. Start with a list of keywords which on 07/25 showed the 7-pack map listings
  2. Narrow down the list to only those that showed the new 3-pack format on 08/15
  3. Retrieve the rank position at which the local pack showed for each date
  4. Compare the visibility of the old 7-pack map listings vs. the new 3-pack local listings

The above methodology narrowed down the keyword set to 53,074 keywords.

Here is what a comparison of the rank distribution shows:

Astoundingly, the new local listing format shows in the #1 rank position 93% of the time – a HUGE increase from the 25% of time that the old 7 pack used to show in the #1 position.


Who loses?

The effects of this change depend on your Enterprise presence. One thing, however, is clear: it is the most disruptive change Google has made to search results in a while – aside from its regular algorithm updates.

The new prominence of local business results means that web-only enterprises that have for years focused on traditional search optimization – and have, as a result, built up tremendous authority and visibility – could be pushed down the page by as many as three rank positions, by companies with a well-optimized local presence.

Take the example of a company such as According to seoClarity’s proprietary keyword research database, it ranks in the Top 10 rank positions for >600,000 hotel-related keywords. This new Local Pack format change means that their true SERP rank has fallen by at least 1 position across 93% or more of those keywords!

Given the difference in click-through rates for each rank position in the search results, falling from No. 1 to No. 2 could lose them between 20 and 30 percent of traffic for those keywords.

The potential impact of this is huge for such web-only enterprises.

Who wins?

Looked at another way, however, this switch represents a huge opportunity for both enterprises with physical locations and smaller local players to monitor and optimize their online presence.

This includes travel agencies, hotel chains, car dealerships, pharmacies, auto parts store and other product and service providers which, for years, lacked the budget, expertise, and cachet of larger competitors — and can now leapfrog their well-heeled web-only competitors and jump into the #1 spot by focusing on local SEO and optimizing their local business listing.

How can you track the impact?

Irrespective of whether this is an opportunity for your Enterprise or a threat, it is important to have visibility into the local pack’s impact on your competitive landscape. And if your Enterprise has physical locations, your rankings WITHIN the local pack are now an area you have to focus on improving your visibility.

seoClarity has developed the ONLY Enterprise scale Local Business Rankings analysis which allows clients to track, monitor, and analyze the visibility of their locations and brands within the Local Listings pack, across the country and down to any specific state, city or even zip code. With this new feature, you can:

  1. Gain insights into your visibility in Google’s Local Business/map results vs. that of your competitors
  2. Compare ratings, reviews and other factors that influence the local business listing rankings within the local pack results
  3. Track changes and the impact and ROI of the same effortlessly across multiple brands and an unlimited number of locations


Request a FREE Walk-through

Mitul Gandhi
Mitul Gandhi
As a longtime data-driven serial entrepreneur, information architect and SEO veteran, Mitul has developed a blend of vast technical expertise and intense marketing insight. His variety of experience, gained in positions in in-house SEO, search marketing, and software development, affords him the ability to efficiently assess how to use software tools to meet challenges and drive ROI. As the Co-Founder and Chief Architect of seoClarity, Mitul currently oversees day-to-day operations, and provides strategic direction to all departments. His well of knowledge includes 10+ years of consulting experience with Fortune 500 and top Internet retailers concerning online search marketing. He has several patents pending for analyzing cause and effect in SEO. Mitul holds an MBA in direct marketing from Rochester Institute of Technology. Additionally, he has spoken at conferences in the United States and the U.K., including SES, SMX and Pubcon. He has also been quoted in MSN Money, USA Today, Time Online, Search Engine Watch, Search Engine Land and Web Pro News.
Recent Posts
Showing 7 comments
  • Clay C

    Just to make sure I’m reading this right: of the >1 million keywords, 53,074 showed showed the 7-pack map listings on 07/25 – roughly 5.3% of the total keyword set. Of that 5.3%, 93% now show that three pack in the #1 spot?

    • Mitul Gandhi

      Hi Clay.. .That is correct… the research data set is a mix of ecommerce, hospitality and local specific keywords… We should have an update on these numbers based on our (larger) competitor keywords data set of >80 million keywords shortly

  • Sonia Pitt

    It’s going to be a cut-throat competition for local rankings in coming days. Even Google is showing Home Servcies Ads with local 3-pack. The SERP is changing so frequently but the problem with the current layout is, most of the time Google is not showing the phone numbers on the local results on SERP. Though they are experimenting, I saw the local listing phone numbers with the reviews in brackets.

    • Ryan Heuser

      Hi Sonia,

      Thanks for commenting! It will certainly be interesting to watch how the local results continue to evolve as Google adapts the SERPs. It seems they will continue to modify and adjust until they find the right “fit”.

  • Yasir


    Have you got any new stats on this?


    • Ryan Heuser

      Hi Yasir,

      Thanks for commenting! We’ve been watching the results and haven’t seen any dramatic shifts, as it appears the results have settled. Local listings are here to stay for the foreseeable future.

  • Steve


    One thing that isn’t really highlighted here, that has had a profound impact, is that the new 3-pack bumps traditional organic listings. Where a well optimized page once ranked #1-3, the 3-pack has bumped them immediately to a blended rank of #4 or worse. The delta in CTR between #1 & #4 is dramatic.

    To counter this, which may be an uphill battle, we’re looking at won/loss across similar keywords to determine possible patterns for when the 3-pack shows and when it doesn’t. I’d love to know if you have any research or commentary on this piece.


Leave a Comment

Top 10 Mobile-Friendly Resultsdashboard-blog